Fire Alarm Panels: Permit or No Permit—That Is the Question

Chris Ramenda Onyx Fire and Safety

To permit, or not to permit. That is the question. Whether ‘tis nobler to endure the slings and arrows of building owners who may think a permit is merely a money-grab lining the contractor’s pockets with “outrageous fortune,” or to maintain the status quo? A quandary indeed.

What we are really debating is the right, appropriate, suitable, legal time to apply for a building permit when installing a new fire-alarm control panel, upgrading an existing one, or replacing an obsolete unit with its modern equivalent.

When I began exploring the issue, I discovered that opinions vary widely. Conversations with building owners often distilled to one question: “What’s the cheapest and fastest solution?” A call to the local fire department about swapping out a failed panel typically produced an emphatic “Yes—restore protection as soon as possible.” By contrast, my local building department responded just as emphatically, “No. Why would you work without a permit?” Definitive answers were not exactly jumping into my boat.

So, what is the real answer? Building owners understandably want to save money and minimize downtime. Fire departments want immediate life-safety protection. Building departments want to ensure the work is performed correctly and documented. The crucial point is that the decision is not yours to make.

You must follow the rules and regulations of the city, town, municipality, or region in which you are working. As a rule of thumb, expect to need a building permit for any major repair, replacement, relocation, addition, new installation, or modification even a like-for-like swap of fire-alarm equipment. If you are unfamiliar with local requirements, contact the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ). In urban areas this is usually the building department; in rural communities it may be the fire department. Make the call, describe the work (or the emergency work already completed), and obtain clear direction.

The permit process varies, but typically you will complete an application outlining the scope of work. A commitment for general review by an architect or engineer may be required, meaning a design professional will assume responsibility and sign off that the project meets code. Sealed drawings, specifications (“cut sheets”), and other design documentation may be requested.

Additional paperwork, such as a life-safety review, helps the plans examiner understand existing systems and can confirm that all requirements are met. Permit fees, of course, are payable up front.

Once submitted, a plans examiner reviews the package. In a perfect world, you receive an approved permit and can proceed. More often, you will receive red-line comments requesting additional information or revisions. Letters from the design professional may be needed to clarify compliance or scope. You can certainly expect examiners’ notes on conformity which must be addressed before work begins.

Execution is next. Ensure compliance with all applicable codes and standards. In Ontario, for example, installing a new fire-alarm control panel requires an electrical permit from the Electrical Safety Authority, a third-party verification inspection to CAN/ULC-S537, and do not be surprised if a CAN/ULC-S1001 integrated-system test is added by the plans examiner among other things.

Sometimes a panel must be replaced over a weekend when offices are closed. Some municipalities may allow an emergency permit in such cases. Restoring a minimum level of safety is paramount, but you must still engage a design professional, pull the permit, provide all required documentation, and complete verification and testing. An emergency does not exempt you from permitting and testing.

Closing the Permit

Each jurisdiction sets its own requirements, but expect to provide:

  • A letter from the design professional (architect or engineer) confirming compliance.
  • A “passed” inspection letter from the electrical authority (e.g., ESA in Ontario).
  • An installation letter from the electrical contractor and a deficiency-free CAN/ULC-S537 verification report.
  • Where required, integrated-system test reports (CAN/ULC-S1001) or CAN/ULC-S561 monitoring certificates.
  • A final field inspection or witness test with the building official, contractor, engineer, and other personnel to demonstrate successful operation.
  • Once the above is complete, a document from the building department stating that the permit is closed.

In Summary

Always do the right thing for the jurisdiction you are in. Research the requirements, make the calls, and you will be glad you did.

“This above all: to thine own self be true, And it must follow, as the night the day, Thou canst not then be false to any man… And the rest is silence.” —Hamlet

Share this article!